Help
Help

So me being the nerd I am, and liking all three of these sets, I decided to find out which one was the best!

Set

Green = 1 point

Yellow = ½ a point

Red = 0 point

15 is max Points

Dragonslayer

Black Knight

Silver Knight

Physical Resis

29.5

30.0

29.3

Strike Def

25.1

25.1

27.1

Slash Def

29.6

26.9

30.7

Thrust Def

29.6

27.3

30.1

Magic Def

25.1

22.4

27.8

Fire Def

28.0

29.9

26.7

Lightning Def

21.2

20.9

24.6

Dark Def

19.5

20.9

44.3

Bleed Resis

151

141

147

Poison Resis

94

100

120

Frost Resis

99

95

109

Curse Resis

85

95

86

Poise

24.7

22.8

25.6

Durability

-

-

-

Weight

32.8

32.0

34.9

Points

6

5.5

9.5

 

Dragonslayer Set:

  • The Dragonslayer’s Set (Ornstein’s), is a fairly balanced armor set with good bleed resistance and poise. Although it’s dark, poison, and curse are lowest of the three it’s decent weight makes up for it. Overall it is not a terrible set but maybe not wearing the full set would be a smarter idea.

 

Black Knight Set:

  • The Black Knight set is something that I find to be slightly disappointing. It does however have the best Physical Defense, Fire Resistance, and Curse resistance out of the three sets. It also has the lightest weight of the three (Only .8 less though, so nothing too notable). But it does not make up for its severe lack in almost every other type of defense. It looks great, but doesn't have any bite.

 

Silver Knight Set:

  • The silver knight set seems to be the best of the three. However, it lacks in its physical resistance, fire defence, and its weight (being 2.1 units heavier than Dragonslayer’s). Overall this set would be good with player with slightly higher Vitality and Vigor (to make up in the lack of Physical Resistance).

Helmet

Green = 1 point

Yellow = ½ a point

Red = 0 point

15 is max Points

Dragonslayer

Black Knight

Silver Knight

Physical Resis

4.6

4.7

4.8

Strike Def

3.8

3.8

4.5

Slash Def

4.6

3.3

5.1

Thrust Def

4.6

4.2

5.0

Magic Def

3.5

3.2

4.7

Fire Def

4.1

4.5

4.5

Lightning Def

4.1

3.0

4.1

Dark Def

2.6

3.6

4.1

Bleed Resis

28

27

24

Poison Resis

18

19

19

Frost Resis

18

19

17

Curse Resis

16

19

13

Poise

3.2

3.0

4.4

Durability

410

400

410

Weight

5.8

5.6

6.1

Points

8

7.5

10.5




Dragonslayer:

  • Good lightning, bleed and durability. Physical and Dark resistance lacking.

 

Black Knight:

  • Good Fire, Poison, Frost, Curse, and Weight. Severely lacking with Slash, Thrust, Magic, and Poise.

 

Silver Knight:

  • Bad Bleed, Frost, Curse, and Weight. Everything else is pretty balanced.

 

Chest

Green = 1 point

Yellow = ½ a point

Red = 0 point

15 is max Points

Dragonslayer


Black Knight



Silver Knight

Physical Resis

14.0

13.8

13.4

Strike Def

12.2

11.7

12.7

Slash Def

14.1

12.7

14.1

Thrust Def

14.1

12.6

13.7

Magic Def

12.4

10.5

12.9

Fire Def

13.5

13.7

12.4

Lightning Def

13.5

9.8

11.4

Dark Def

10.0

11.5

11.4

Bleed Resis

64

58

65

Poison Resis

40

42

55

Frost Resis

43

39

50

Curse Resis

36

39

39

Poise

12.2

10.4

12.8

Durability

420

410

420

Weight

14.4

13.9

15.0

Points

9

6

10.5




Dragonslayer:

  • Pretty balanced, but is lacking in Dark and Poison Defense.

 

Black Knight:

  • Pretty bad, has good Fire, Dark, Curse, and Weight though.

 

Silver Knight:

  • Lacking in Physical Defence, Fire and Weight. Everything else is pretty good.

 

Gauntlets

Green = 1 point

Yellow = ½ a point

Red = 0 point

15 is max Points

Dragonslayer

Black Knight

Silver Knight

Physical Resis

3.5

3.4

3.5

Strike Def

2.9

2.9

2.9

Slash Def

3.5

3.3

3.6

Thrust Def

3.5

3.1

3.6

Magic Def

3.2

2.5

2.9

Fire Def

3.6

3.4

2.8

Lightning Def

3.6

2.3

2.5

Dark Def

2.4

2.8

2.5

Bleed Resis

21

18

22

Poison Resis

13

12

18

Frost Resis

14

11

17

Curse Resis

12

11

14

Poise

2.9

2.7

2.0

Durability

400

400

400

Weight

4.2

4.0

4.7

Points

10.5

5.5

11

 

Dragonslayer:

  • Only notably bad thing is the Dark Resistance. Other than that is looks all good. Only .5 away from being the same level as Silver Knight so maybe it could be used as a replacement.

 

Black Knight:

  • Awful. There are so many reds. I would just consider not using these gauntlets.

 

Silver Knight:

  • Weight, Poise, and Fire defense are lacking, but other than that it looks pretty good.  

Boots

Green = 1 point

Yellow = ½ a point

Red = 0 point

15 is max Points

Dragonslayer

Black Knight

Silver Knight

Physical Resis

7.4

8.1

7.6

Strike Def

6.2

6.7

7.0

Slash Def

7.4

7.6

7.9

Thrust Def

7.4

4.4

7.8

Magic Def

6.0

6.2

7.3

Fire Def

6.8

8.3

7.0

Lightning Def

6.8

5.8

6.3

Dark Def

4.5

6.9

6.3

Bleed Resis

38

38

36

Poison Resis

23

27

28

Frost Resis

24

26

25

Curse Resis

21

26

20

Poise

6.4

6.7

6.4

Durability

410

400

400

Weight

8.4

8.5

9.1

Points

5.5

11

9

 

Dragonslayer:

  • Honestly really bad. It’s Lightning and Bleed are the only things that are notably better.

 

Black Knight:

  • Arguably the best piece of the Black Knight set, only lacking in thrust and Lightning defense.

 

Silver Knight:

  • Not fantastic, but not terrible. It’s weight is still a problem.

 

Silver Knight Helmet, Gauntlets, Chest, with Black Knight Boots.

 

Silver Knight

Helmet

Silver Knight

Chest

Silver Knight

Gauntlets

Black Knight

Boots

Total

Physical Resis

4.8

13.4

3.5

8.1

29.8

Strike Def

4.5

12.7

2.9

6.7

26.8

Slash Def

5.1

14.1

3.6

7.6

33.4

Thrust Def

5.0

13.7

3.6

4.4

26.7

Magic Def

4.7

12.9

2.9

6.2

26.7

Fire Def

4.5

12.4

2.8

8.3

28.0

Lightning Def

4.1

11.4

2.5

5.8

23.8

Dark Def

4.1

11.4

2.5

6.9

24.9

Bleed Resis

24

65

22

38

149

Poison Resis

19

55

18

27

119

Frost Resis

17

50

17

26

110

Curse Resis

13

39

14

26

92

Poise

4.4

12.8

2.0

6.7

25.9

Durability

410

420

400

400

1630

Weight

6.1

15.0

4.7

8.5

34.3

Points

10.5

10.5

11

11

43

 

Sets V2

Green = 2

Yellow = 1

Orange = ½

Red = 0

30 max

Dragonslayer

Black Knight

Silver Knight

Silver Black Combo

Physical Resis

29.5

30.0

29.3

29.8

Strike Def

25.1

25.1

27.1

26.8

Slash Def

29.6

26.9

30.7

33.4

Thrust Def

29.6

27.3

30.1

26.7

Magic Def

25.1

22.4

27.8

26.7

Fire Def

28.0

29.9

26.7

28.0

Lightning Def

21.2

20.9

24.6

23.8

Dark Def

19.5

20.9

44.3

24.9

Bleed Resis

151

141

147

149

Poison Resis

94

100

120

119

Frost Resis

99

95

109

110

Curse Resis

85

95

86

92

Poise

24.7

22.8

25.6

25.9

Durability

1640

1610

1340

1630

Weight

32.8

32.0

34.9

34.3

Points

2.5

11

16

16.5

 

Overall Judgement:

    Although Very close, the Silver and the Silver/ Black combo barely beat it by .5 points! I would use this set in combat! But beware thrusting weapons! I will probably stick with this and build up some Vitality and use Havel’s ring along with Favour and Protection.





Add me on PSN if you want: GEMERALSHPHERD

 

 




Load more

Chat